In Daredevil, Matt Murdock stretches himself thin trying to be a hero, a lawyer and a friend all at once. He tries to do too much, and as a consequence, things are left unfinished or neglected. Just like its main character, Daredevil’s second season stretches itself across too many subplots, and it leaves the show muddled and shallow.
A big part of season one’s success had to do with the conflict between Daredevil and Wilson Fisk. That might seem obvious, but it’s precisely what season two was lacking. Everything that happened in season one could be boiled down to that battle between Daredevil and Fisk. In season two, the villains come and go, changing allegiances or disappearing in a flash.
Fisk worked so well as a villain because he had a clear goal: taking over Hell’s Kitchen. And that goal permeated the entire season. In season two, our first villain is Frank Castle, A.K.A. The Punisher. He’s one a one-man rampage against organized crime, and he even bests Daredevil right off the bat.
The back-and-forth between the two characters over their similarities and differences makes for some great dialogue. But Punisher is apprehended after just a few episodes, and the show suddenly turns into a legal drama.